(818) 995-9452
Manslaughter and murder are two of the most severe offenses punishable under California law. However, there are important distinctions between the two crimes, especially regarding potential sentencing. California defendants need to understand manslaughter vs. murder and how their legal differences can impact a criminal case.
If you are facing manslaughter or murder charges in California, don’t answer any police questions before consulting an experienced criminal defense attorney. Contact the Law Offices of Justin E. Sterling immediately to discuss your legal rights in a free consultation.
Murder vs. Manslaughter in California
California’s murder statute defines homicide as the unlawful killing of a human being or a fetus with malice aforethought. This means the alleged perpetrator thought about their actions at least briefly before killing someone and deliberately intended to take their life.
By contrast, California law defines manslaughter as the unlawful killing of a human being without malice. Manslaughter charges in California still involve an unlawful killing, but the lack of intent and malice make this charge less severe than murder.
Why Does the Distinction Matter?
The difference between murder and manslaughter in California is critical if you’re facing charges related to allegedly committing a violent crime. A murder conviction carries the harshest penalties under state law, including life in prison or the death penalty in extreme cases. Manslaughter, while still a serious offense, has comparatively lighter penalties and may allow for parole or reduced prison time.
Prosecutors often base murder and manslaughter charges on intent. Murder requires the state to prove you acted with malice, but manslaughter applies when someone’s death resulted from your reckless or impulsive actions. If you’re accused of killing someone, a skilled defense attorney can challenge the prosecution’s case and argue for lesser criminal charges. Your lawyer may present evidence showing that you didn’t intend to kill anyone or that you acted in the heat of the moment. A reduced charge could mean the difference between decades behind bars and a chance at rebuilding your life.
Types of Murder
California law separates murder charges into first-degree and second-degree murder based on the alleged perpetrator’s intent and other facts of the case.
First-degree murder: involves deliberate, premeditated killings. To convict a defendant of first-degree murder, the prosecution must show that the accused planned the act ahead of time or killed someone using specific methods mentioned in state law (e.g., poisoning, lying in wait, or torture). First-degree murder also includes felony murder, which applies when someone dies during the commission of a severe felony (e.g., robbery, arson, or kidnapping), even if the killing was unintentional.
Second-degree murder: refers to killings that weren’t premeditated but still involved reckless disregard for human life. For example, if someone acted intentionally but without prior planning — such as in a fit of rage or by firing a gun into a crowd — they could face second-degree murder charges.
Types of Manslaughter
California law identifies three types of manslaughter charges:
- Voluntary – Occurs when someone kills another person in the heat of the moment, usually in a quarrel that drives someone to act without thinking
- Involuntary – When a death results from a person’s reckless or criminally negligent actions but they had no intent to kill
- Vehicular – Involves deaths resulting from reckless or illegal actions by a driver (e.g., drunk driving)
Can You Get a Murder Charge Reduced to Manslaughter?
It is possible to have a murder charge reduced to manslaughter in California. A criminal defense lawyer will analyze the facts of the case and look for evidence discounting the prosecution’s claim of intent to kill. Your defense lawyer might also challenge the quality of the prosecution’s evidence, question witness credibility, or present mitigating factors like self-defense or provocation. Remember, you are innocent until proven guilty in the criminal justice system.
Prosecutors sometimes agree to reduced charges in plea deals when the evidence for murder isn’t strong enough to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The right legal strategy can mean the difference between a lifetime behind bars and a more manageable sentence.
Penalties and Sentencing
Murder and manslaughter penalties in California differ significantly while still imposing harsh punishments on defendants convicted of either offense. Voluntary manslaughter convictions can result in three to 11 years in state prison.
Involuntary manslaughter carries a sentence of two to four years. Vehicular manslaughter penalties depend on the circumstances, with the most extreme cases leading to up to 10 years in prison.
Murder convictions in California come with far harsher penalties. First-degree murder carries a sentence of 25 years to life in state prison, and cases involving special circumstances — such as multiple victims or the killing of a police officer — can result in life without parole or even the death penalty.
Second-degree murder convictions carry 15 years to life in prison, though certain factors, like repeat offenses or using a firearm to kill someone, can increase the sentence. Because these penalties can change significantly based on the specifics of a case, anyone facing murder or manslaughter charges needs a strong legal defense team to help them fight for a fair outcome.
Role of the Jury in Murder and Manslaughter Cases
In California, juries play a crucial role in deciding whether a defendant is guilty of murder or manslaughter. During a trial, the defense can argue that the defendant didn’t plan the killing in advance or that they committed a crime of passion. If the jury agrees, they may convict the defendant of manslaughter instead of murder, leading to a significantly lighter sentence. A skilled criminal defense attorney can present evidence showing the defendant’s state of mind, challenging the prosecution’s claims of intent, and highlighting mitigating factors to bolster the argument for a reduced charge.
Contact a Los Angeles Homicide Defense Lawyer to Discuss Your Case Today
As a former Los Angeles Public Defender and seasoned defense attorney, Justin E. Sterling has successfully defended many clients accused of violent crimes, including murder and manslaughter. In one recent criminal case, our law firm secured a not-guilty verdict for a client facing three charges of premeditated attempted murder.
No matter what criminal charges you face or how dire things seem, our law firm will guide you through the legal process, protect your rights, and work to mitigate your charges and penalties. Call or contact The Law Offices of Justin E. Sterling today for a free consultation with an experienced criminal defense lawyer.
